Enemy Mine: Engaging the Enemy (#moodle)

Note: This is an adaptation of a blog entry I wrote some time ago…not sure where, or if, I submitted it for publication anywhere, but I had fun writing it and stumbled across it in my GoogleDocs “file folder!” It features a list and contributions submitted via comments on that blog entry. Many thanks to those who contributed!

Teaching online often seems like science fiction for some teachers. It’s alien as watching an episode of Star Trek or one of those movies where humans find themselves marooned on an alien planet. For many of us, understanding what learning might happen in a virtual classroom–as facilitated by Moodle course management system–can be tough as surviving the cold of space. In this article, you’ll be introduced to several ways educators around the world are using Moodle in their classroom.

As an avid reader of science fiction, one of my favorite tales is that of Enemy Mine. In it, two warring races, fighting for conquest of the space they co-inhabit, are forced to survive in a rugged, inhospitable environment. Only together can they survive, only together can they find life and a measure of peace and happiness. The harsh conditions force them to reach back to the very values that the movie implies all denizens of the universe share:

Davidge (Human)“If one receives evil from another, let one not do evil in return. Rather, let him extend love to the enemy, that love might unite them.” I’ve heard all this before… in the human Taalmaan.
Jerry (Reptilian Alien): Of course you have. Truth is truth.


Truth is truth, but in schools today, some have suggested that our students are the enemy. Sylvia Martinez (GenYes.com vendor) shares a story about a presentation title at the NYSCATE  conference called, “The Enemy Within: Stop Students from Bypassing Your Web Filters“. The presentation is by Chris Ridgway (Sophos vendor) and is described in this way:

How can you detect and block anonymizing proxies to stop students from accessing content which can create security risks to your network? Sophos security expert, Chris Ridgeway, will discuss risks posed by Web 2.0., how anonymizing proxies compound that threat and best practices to thwart anonymizing proxies in your network.


The presentation title has generated a lot of commentary and you can read the lengthy comments posted on the wiki for the Conference. However, as a school district administrator, it is not surprising to me that this perspective exists. Mr. Ridgway’s behavior is objectionable because he gave voice to the perspective THAT DOES EXIST in our public schools today. In fact, it would not be inaccurate to realize that while some school districts would never admit to it, they do perceive students and educators who use social media tools in the following way as enemies:

The next crop of terrorists are still at school, preparing for their SAT tests. They are probably bright, politically disinterested and easily susceptible to the ideology of the Read/Write Web. They receive a daily diet of anti-school establishment propaganda through Web 2.0 and so-called social networking websites. Young children of immigrants still at school are among those linked to guerilla conspiracies. The path from adolescent dreamer interested in moblogs to flash mob radicals ready to engage in peaceful school walkouts to immigration issues and posting embarrassing videos of irrelevant teachers on YouTube can be frighteningly short. Web 2.0 guerilla-teachers are looking to groom and brainwash our children as advocates for passionate action, conflict over harmony, transparency over invulnerability, and commitment to virtual friends, and real life strangers. The teenblogosphere is without restraint.
Source: Around the Corner – http://bit.ly/ohL2X


This perspective presents some challenges to school district administrators and teachers that should raise questions in our mind about the fundamental purpose of schools, teaching, and learning. As a reformed guerilla-teacher working to circumvent and build capacity at the classroom and campus level–often with the support of a principal tired of waiting for the school district to deliver on its promise of technical support and funding–I find myself trying to find ways to “engage” students and teachers.

OASIS IN VIRTUAL SPACE – MOODLE
Our approach as educators in schools today can often mean that we fail to consult the people we “advocate” for–our students. As fundamentalists engaged in jihad, we fail to engage in conversation the very learners for whom we pretend to serve. Adopting any technology, but Moodle course management system in particular, we are forced to reconsider our motivations and how we support teaching and learning in the classroom.  In fact, in an article by S. Lowes (available online), the following quote struck me:

As teachers adapt their courses for the online environment, they are forced to reexamine the course design, reconsider curriculum strategies, and make many decisions about what to take out and what to keep, what to add and what to substitute. . .[one teacher shared] “By developing my [online] course, I have had the opportunity to introspectively analyze what I am teaching, why I teach the way I do, and how I can change and improve my communication with students”
Source: The Trans-Classroom Teacher, http://www.innovateonline.info/index.php?view=article&id=446&action=article


As teachers begin to work online with their students, there is a clear recognition that “The Net Generation is growing up in a tool-rich environment and this needs to be taken into account in designing pedagogical systems” (Source: 
Philip, D. 2007. The Knowledge Building paradigm: A model of learning for Net Generation students. Innovate 3 (5). http://www.innovateonline.info/index.php?view=article&id=368).

One of the primary tools you can use as an online learning facilitator is Moodle. This virtual classroom tool provides you with the benefits of a web site but with many more built-in learning activities for your students. You can easily arrange instructional materials, activities within this online space, as well as facilitate discussions online. Moodle allows you to create an online learning center for you and your students to work in that is safe and allows you to extend learning beyond the classroom walls. For many, Moodle is one-stop shopping solution for blogs, wikis, podcasts, survey questionnaires that print incredible graphs, quizzes; take grades, and institute online forums with attachments.

ENGAGING THE ENEMY
If our students are perceived as the enemy, then how do we engage these avid learners, so captivated by technology that facilitates very human ways of interacting with each other? One obvious way is to use tools like Moodle that enable the creation of virtual learning settings that can transform our world. Consider that Moodle, a course management system, can be used in many different ways.

Long-time Moodle using educators recently shared a variety of ways in which they are using Moodle in their classrooms. Below is a list of instructional scenarios that I found worth blogging about (Around the Corner-MGuhlin.org) and I am grateful to have the opportunity to share with you via onCUE. This list came my way via Ken Task in Texas, and to which fellow educator, Dan McGuire, volunteered to add more to. The following is a list of some of what you can do with Moodle, the free, open source course management system. The list comes from Ken Task, who cites ISTE Moodle Ning and Susan Sedro.


Scenario 1: Student Blogging
Students can record their impressions and reactions to events and activities presented throughout the school year. Reflection on what is learned is critical for both students and teachers. Using the built-in blogging tools, Moodle can be used to facilitate reflection of online and offline learning activities. Furthermore, these activities can be enhanced through the use of additional modules that can be installed on Moodle. For example, if you are working with second language learners, students can record audio that is embedded in discussion forums and blogs. Using Real Simple Syndication (RSS), this audio can be published as a podcast without any extra effort on the part of the teacher, aside from initial setup.

Of course, if this work is to remain between student and teacher–replacing those cumbersome folders and Mead notebooks–then the students and the instructor are the only ones that can see the blog entries. In other words, students cannot see other students’ blogs. This activity will be graded on a rubric and after the grading, students will be able to see other student blogs.

Scenario 2: Tracking Student Content with RSS
Many of the activities in Moodle have Real Simple Syndication (RSS) feeds. RSS is critical to the idea of Web 2.0 because any content you can create, others can subscribe to if RSS is enabled. If you setup several discussion forums in a course, it can be difficult to track them across multiple periods, especially at the high school level. To facilitate awareness concerning new information in each of them, teachers, parents, and students can subscribe to the RSS feed for each of the forums. These can be managed in a locally installed RSS reader (e.g. Feedrocket for Windows, NetNewsWire for Mac) or a web-based RSS reader (e.g. Bloglines.com, Google Reader). Either way, instead of having to visit the discussion forums to see what has changed a la Web 1.0, interested parties can subscribe to the content and be updated when it changes via RSS.

Scenario 3: Podcasting with Moodle
This school year, an urban school district joined the ranks of many that are using iPods to facilitate second language learning. Using iPods or MP3 players, content can be loaded on those video/audio media can be loaded on these portable media devices. However, with a little planning, you are not limited to just loading content from sources like United Streaming and other third party vendors. Students can create their own content using the Audio Recorder Module in Moodle (there are other modules, too) and those can be shared as part of the RSS feed that students subscribe to. In other words, digital video/audio can feature student-created content–such as reflections on the instructional content being shared with them–alongside the commercial content, such as that coming from United Streaming. Using the podcast module in Moodle, both students and teacher can post podcasts that can be subscribed to in iTunes or via RSS readers (e.g. GoogleReader).

Scenario 4: Peer Review
Whether you are working as an English/Language Arts teacher or in a different content area, the ability to share work online and get it peer-reviewed is a valuable skill. While many of us are familiar with writing groups that review content, this idea of reviewing content in a safe, virtual space is foreign to us. Moodle enables this by allowing students to write something (e.g. personal narrative, essay) and allow peer review. Students are placed in collaborative groups and each student reviews the short stories of other members in their group. Each student can critique and offer suggestions to their teammates as well as be graded. When peer review is complete, students are encouraged to revise their written pieces and place them online for publication.


Using a wiki, student groups can collaborate on create resources for each other about a particular topic or learning objectives.

Scenario 5: Online Student-Teacher Collaboration
High school students often have a need to learn academic topic in a social environment. This can often involve students connecting after-hours in a Moodle course. Moodles built-in collaboration tools that are synchronous (e.g. live chat) and instant messaging that can be archived (as often required to satisfy safety requirements for use of chat in schools). In addition to student-to-student conversations, teachers can also host after-hours “office hours” online that can include audio conversations in a safe online environment. Modules and customizations (Tip: Use NanoGong) enable enable voice support for Moodle. For example, one module to facilitate this is NanoGong. Its authors describe it in this way:


The NanoGong activity is an exercise that can be put on a course. Every student in the course can submit several voice recordings together with optional text messages using the activity. Teachers in the course can then examine these submissions, give comments and assign a score to each of them.

Combining voice, text, chat communications can definitely turbo-charge your interactions with students. While you could use a variety of Web 2.0 tools to provide this kind of support, Moodle centralizes the tool-set that you use with your students in a context you can actually introduce at school.

Scenario 6: Connecting with Parents
Parents often seek information about helping their child in something. I want to allow parents of my students to be able to access my online class, see their childs work ONLY, and interact with me online during after school office hours. I want to do this inside the online system. Dan McGuire shares the following about his experiences using Moodle with 4th grade students:


This is one of the most practical features of Moodle. Last year I taught a 4th grade class. One of our standard weekly assignments was to use each of the twenty words from our weekly spelling list in a separate sentence. Students had the option of creating a story with the sentences or not. I would vary the particular requirements depending on the skills we were working on that week – two subjects in each sentence, two verbs, more than one adjective, etc.

Using Moodle for this exercise is particularly helpful for students who want a little extra help from parents or siblings. It allows parents to know what the assignment without worrying about lost papers, etc. Students don’t need to worry about hauling paper or notebooks back and forth from home to school. I showed the students how to use Google translate which was useful for a few ( There were several Somali speakers in my room and the translation capabilities for Somali aren’t very good yet, though. It worked great for the Spanish speakers.) I also took advantage of the relationship our school has with the U of Mn I was fortunate to be able to work with the great grad students in the Teaching Smart program. Several of the grad students took on tutor roles and made comments on student work. This was particularly useful in the science writing assignments we did, which were a variation of the above. In the science assignments students were to describe the activities of a science experiment that we did.


As you can see from Dan’s experience, Moodle was able to involve people from within and outside the classroom, engaging all in a learning conversation that benefited students.

Scenario 7: International Community Conversations
No matter what your content area, students and teachers are engaged when they can connect to primary sources. One such activity can involve the teaching of History and/or Social Studies. Imagine how students from your class can participate in a telecollaborative experiment with a class from another school, city, state, or country. Both classes would be able to access a single History course via the Moodle course where they can contribute a local multimedia history of their community and share that information. Moodle makes it very easy for both classes to embed content, such as from ShowBeyond.com or VoiceThread.com, in discussion forums and/or group blogs (Tip: Create group blogs with the OUBlog module).

Students in the local class concentrate on the local history of their community, while those in the other locale concentrate their media-collection and organization efforts on their own community. Students in both classes are able to work collaboratively to construct a local history, as well as create a photo gallery (Tip: Use Lightbox Gallery module), podcasts, post video/audio clips of historical locations within their own communities. The students from either sister community will be able to ask each other questions and share information (as well as files) in a safe online environment.

Scenario 8: Administrator Oversight
When introducing any virtual tool that involves students and adults interacting online, there can be concern about digital citizenship. Simply put, are students behaving well online? Campus–and district–administrators can login to teacher courses to see how these interactions are occurring and then provide helpful feedback to teachers and students. Valuable insights can be gained, not only into the teacher, but also how students are interacting (appropriately or no).


Scenario 9: Interactive Writing Feedback
Students can draft their writing in a word processor, then paste it into the Assignment module. The teacher can not only score it, but also provide feedback online without having to print out the content. It can also be useful to involve local university students to provide this feedback to students as peer editors for student work.


Scenario 10: Learning Diary with Teacher Feedback
Using the Learning Diary module, students can write about a particular assignment and I can respond and provide feedback without other students seeing that exchange. This replaces the old paper journal where students write questions, reflections and the teacher writes back.

Update to Scenario 10 by Dan McGuire:

This worked well with in conjunction with particular reading assignments. I would usually post the questions that I wanted students for student response. It is especially useful to then ask for volunteers to let me show their work on the projector and make comments in writing on the screen. This is one of the best writing teaching tools since the invention of the pencil.. Most students at this age are eager to have their work critiqued in front of other students. I’ve found they actually enjoy doing editing, which is certainly not the case when you ask a nine year old to rewrite 200 words they’ve just struggled to get on paper with a pencil. The computer gives them a power with making words that they don’t have with a pencil and paper.


Scenario 11: Online Literature Circles
When you think of literature circles, we think of kids sitting in a circle reading books and sharing their thoughts on it based on the role they are assigned. Discussing books helps children build connections, sets a purpose for reading beyond the intrinsic motivation we all prize, and motivates them. It also helps them, read, observe, question, discuss, answer questions, and write about what they are reading. It’s a fantastic activity, rich with opportunities for reflective learning. Students can post online book talks to persuade other group membes to choose their book for literature circles, vote on book selections, and they use the Moodle discussion forums to discuss their book, upload images, etc.

Update to Scenario 11 (Contributed by Dan McGuire):
I used both the forum module and the workshop module to do writing circles. The forum module is a little easier to manage. I found setting up the workshop module to be still a bit cumbersome. I hope to practice with it more this year because I think it has tremendous possibilities.
The trick to using the forum module was that students were required to write something new about each of the prompts that were the forum topics. This forced the students to read what others had written and then got them back into the text because I insisted on quotes from the text to support their opinions. Students were only permitted to disagree with another student if they proved their point with quotes from the text.

ENEMY MINE
Like enemies who have crash-landed on a barren rock, technology directors, students and teachers must get past their competing desires for comfort and particular approaches to find common ways to learn together. Rigid adherence to pedagogy, technology commandments writ by the hand of fearful administrators, and hurtful applications of technology inhibit successful learning environments. Why not use Moodle to establish an oasis in virtual space?



References
Image Source for Enemy Mine – Movie Poster Available Online 01/2010 – http://www.impawards.com/1985/enemy_mine.html


Subscribe to Around the Corner-MGuhlin.org


Everything posted on Miguel Guhlin’s blogs/wikis are his personal opinion and do not necessarily represent the views of his employer(s) or its clients. Read Full Disclosure


Discover more from Another Think Coming

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

2 comments

  1. Miguel, you always please. I especially loved this quote "Moodle was able to involve people from within and outside the classroom, engaging all in a learning conversation that benefited students" re: Dan's experiences using Moodle in the classroom to enable work to go home where parents were encouraged to be involved.Thanks for sharing!

  2. Miguel, you always please. I especially loved this quote “Moodle was able to involve people from within and outside the classroom, engaging all in a learning conversation that benefited students” re: Dan's experiences using Moodle in the classroom to enable work to go home where parents were encouraged to be involved.Thanks for sharing!

Leave a comment