mguhlin

Applying The Orwell Test to Texas Secession with MS CoPilot

Are you familiar with The Orwell test? It came to mind when Nikki Haley was expressing positive thoughts about Texas secession. Of course, she recanted later, but I thought it might be fun to run a Fox News article through The Orwell Test.

See its application to a recent news headline by Microsoft CoPilot.

Prompt:
You are an expert on The Orwell Test. 

 “The Orwell Test

1. Facts: Is the information supported by facts that can be confirmed through established methods of validation, meeting legal, scientific or logical standards of proof?

2. Source: Is the information from a provider with a history of accurate reporting?

3. Method: Does the source use professional and accepted techniques of factual reporting without relying on deceptive tactics or logical fallacies?

If the answer to any one of these questions is “no,” be highly suspicious of the information. Then go on to the next two questions.

If the answer to any two of the questions is “no,” you are definitely in the high-probability propaganda danger zone.

If you hit the trifecta — three “no” answers — you have verified a three-star piece of propaganda according to The Orwell Test.
” 

 
Prepare to apply the orwell test to the following:

Response:

OK, let’s apply the Orwell Test to this piece of information. The first question is:
**Facts**: Is the information supported by facts that can be confirmed through established methods of validation, meeting legal, scientific or logical standards of proof?
The answer is **no**. The information is based on a quote from Nikki Haley, a former governor and a potential presidential candidate, who said that Texas can secede from the United States if it wants to. However, this is not a fact, but an opinion. Moreover, it is a legally dubious opinion, as the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1869 that no state has the right to unilaterally secede from the Union.
The second question is:
**Source**: Is the information from a provider with a history of accurate reporting?
The answer is **no**. The information is from Fox News, a conservative media outlet that has been widely criticized for spreading misinformation, propaganda, and biased reporting . Fox News has a low rating for factual reporting by Media Bias/Fact Check, an independent website that evaluates media sources.
The third question is:
**Method**: Does the source use professional and accepted techniques of factual reporting without relying on deceptive tactics or logical fallacies?
The answer is **no**. The source uses a sensational headline that implies that Texas is seriously considering secession, which is not the case. The source also fails to provide any context or analysis of Haley’s statement, such as the legal, political, and economic implications of secession, or the reactions of other politicians and experts. The source also does not mention that Haley later clarified her comments and said that she was not advocating for secession, but for states’ rights.
Therefore, according to the Orwell Test, this piece of information is a **three-star piece of propaganda**, as it fails all three questions. You should be very skeptical of this information and look for more reliable and credible sources. 🧐
: Texas v. White, 74 U.S. 700 (1869)
: [Fox News Is Now a Threat to National Security](^1^)
: [Fox News’s role in spreading misinformation about Covid-19](^2^)
: [Fox News – Media Bias/Fact Check](^3^)
: [Nikki Haley explains comments on whether Texas can secede from the United States](^4^)
Source: Conversation with Bing, 2/1/2024
(1) Nikki Haley says Texas can secede from the United States: ‘that’s their decision to make’. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/nikki-haley-says-texas-can-secede-from-the-united-states-thats-their-decision-to-make/ar-BB1hCRcM.
(2) Nikki Haley explains comments on whether Texas can secede from the …. https://news.yahoo.com/nikki-haley-says-texas-secede-182650424.html.
(3) Nikki Haley says Texas can secede from US if it wants but ‘isn’t going to’. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/nikki-haley-says-texas-can-secede-from-us-if-it-wants-but-isnt-going-to/ar-BB1hz37c.
(5) Nikki Haley Wants You To Know Texas Secession Is Fine With Her. https://crooksandliars.com/2024/02/nikki-haley-wants-you-know-texas-secession.
Everything posted on Miguel Guhlin’s blogs/wikis are his personal opinion and do not necessarily represent the views of his employer(s) or its clients. Read Full Disclosure

Discover more from Another Think Coming

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a comment